I often read many webcomics that attempt to make a scene more “memorable” or hook more readers in by doing this “subversion of expectations” tactic where they twist something in the story to catch readers off-guard. However, I really don’t get how this strategy is supposed to work because it often is not executed like a twist where the twist is somewhat foreshadowed to give the reader at least an inkling of what is happening.
One of the most common kind of subversions of expectations is for when two characters are talking about some kind of agreement and suddenly the main character goes and does something totally unthinkable in that situation. It often just makes me scratch my head and ask myself, “What the hell am I reading?
I would list examples but there are so many that I think it would be more worthwhile to list my reasons for why I think this tactic is just not as effective as following the reader’s expectations. One of my favorite webcomics that follows expectations is Another Typical Fantasy Romance Novel which is the perfect example of a story that does exactly what you expect and executes it in such a way that you get more satisfaction out of reading it than these supposed subversion of expectations stories.
The way the story manages to be not completely predictable is by leaving little holes and gaps for how the end goal of each issue is resolved leaving room for readers to guess the plot but maintaining a level of predictability that ensures the reader never leaves because the story didn’t go the way they expected. Because of this, I have continued following this webcomic for over a year already even though I am not really a big fan of romance novels.
It does also help that the characterization of the major players in the story are especially distinct and the author manages to develop characters that are predictable yet deep allowing the author to have holes in the solution but still have the end goal clearly defined throughout the whole story. It also helps that the story never “backpedals” which is a big issue I have with other romance novels.
By keeping the progress of the romance at a steady but slow progress and making the end results predictable, the author of the webcomic is able to add small variations within each arc to prevent the story from becoming stale while also providing the readers with a satisfying conclusion to each arc.







